Recreating that classic Southern comfort food experience right in your own kitchen is easier than you think. I have gathered 18 Cracker Barrel copycat recipes that deliver all those cozy restaurant vibes without leaving the house.
Get ready to fill your table with hearty favorites that taste just like the real deal.
1. Cracker Barrel Campfire S’more
Get ready for a serious treat involving a sinful fudge brownie on a graham cracker crust. You top the whole thing with toasted marshmallow and chocolate for a huge mouthful of goodness.
I suggest baking the brownie base and letting it cool before you broil that fluffy topping to serve it immediately. Simply add the marshmallows during the last five minutes of baking if you prefer a warm dessert.
2. Cracker Barrel Mashed Potatoes
Mashed potatoes are truly one of those stellar sides that pair well with almost anything. Russet potatoes work best for this specific dish.
You simply season the spuds to your taste. Mix in some butter to finish off this easy comfort food.
3. Cracker Barrel Chocolate Pecan Pie
Pecan pie is a perfect slice of sweet and crunchy goodness. Adding chocolate to the mix certainly does not ruin a thing.
This recipe yields an amazing pie but you can stick with your favorite base if you prefer. All you have to do is toss in some semi sweet chocolate chips.
4. Cracker Barrel Mushroom Pot Roast
Mushrooms instantly elevate a standard pot roast to something special. They provide a fantastic earthy flavor even though they do not cook directly with the meat.
You must always sear the meat first to create a tasty crust. Let the roast cook low and slow for a few hours to get the best results.
5. Cracker Barrel Baby Limas
Make sure you cook your lima beans with savory ingredients like bacon and garlic. You also add onion powder and red pepper flakes alongside chicken bouillon for maximum flavor.
I know lima beans are sometimes a hard sell. These buttery and flavorful beans will definitely have you reaching for seconds.
6. Broccoli Cheddar Chicken (Cracker Barrel Copycat)
I am a massive fan of the classic broccoli and cheddar combination. Adding chicken turns those delicious flavors into a complete meal.
You can easily swap the cheddar soup for cream of chicken or mushroom soup if you prefer. I love adding Ritz crackers on top for a delightful toasty crunch.
7. Copycat Cracker Barrel Sausage Gravy And Biscuits
This version rivals any gravy made from bacon grease thanks to the delicious chunks of sausage. You cook the meat first and stir it back into the finished gravy at the very end.
Store bought mixes make biscuits easy but homemade dough lets you experiment. I personally love adding cheddar and jalapeno to my biscuits.
8. Cracker Barrel Strawberry Shortcake
You should absolutely go crazy making everything from scratch if you have the time. Store bought ingredients work perfectly when you need something sweet in a hurry.
I chop the strawberries and toss them in sugar for extra sweetness. The delicious juices will start to flow after the fruit sits for about ten minutes.
9. Copycat Cracker Barrel Chicken and Dumplings
Chicken and dumplings might just be the most essential Southern dish of all time. The biscuit style crust found here pairs beautifully with the creamy chicken.
I know dumplings vary by region but this version is worth trying. It honestly does not get much better than this classic Cracker Barrel meal.
10. Homemade Chicken Potpie
I always vow to make chicken pot pie more often because it tastes so delicious. This recipe is simple enough that I could whip it up every single week.
You can cut down prep time significantly by using store bought pie dough and frozen veggies. Leftover rotisserie chicken makes it possible to have dinner ready in just thirty minutes.
11. Cracker Barrel’s White Gravy
I never experienced the wonders of white gravy as a child living outside the South. I wrongly assumed it took forever to make and would be impossible to master.
Anyone who can make a white sauce can easily handle this gravy. You start by cooking bacon and using that same pan to keep the flavor.
Stir the flour until it browns and add the milk slowly to avoid lumps.
12. Cracker Barrel Cherry Chocolate Cobbler
Chocolate and cherry go hand in hand perfectly. There is no rule saying you cannot add a little decadence to your cobbler mix.
This dessert is incredibly easy thanks to pre made cherry pie filling. You simply add melted chocolate to the topping for a rich finish.
13. Cracker Barrel Sunday Homestyle Chicken
It is a shame Cracker Barrel only serves this chicken on Sundays because I would eat it daily. You should start with uniform chicken pieces to ensure they cook evenly.
Let the meat sit in buttermilk for an hour if possible. Double dip the chicken in buttermilk and flour for the best coating and cook in batches to avoid overcrowding.
14. Cracker Barrel Corn Bread Dressing
This dish is a savory side similar to stuffing rather than a salad dressing. It incorporates familiar flavors like sage and onion.
The main difference here is the delicious addition of cornbread. It cooks just like any other stuffing recipe and pairs perfectly with roasted chicken.
15. Copycat Cracker Barrel Hash Brown Casserole Recipe
Potatoes are welcome on my plate in absolutely any form. I enjoy them boiled or fried but crispy hash browns make me feel warm inside.
You add cream of chicken soup to this recipe for a kick of great flavor. This dish works as a perfect side for morning eggs or dinner pork chops.
16. Cracker Barrel Ham and Egg Casserole
This breakfast casserole is absolutely terrific. It features a sourdough base and a simple cheesy egg filling that feels satisfying and warm.
I think it tastes great alongside hash browns. Feel free to swap the ham for bacon or sausage and throw in some onion.
17. Kale and Brussels Sprouts Salad (Cracker Barrel)
Cracker Barrel offers more than just heavy meals. This salad is a winner whether you want a fresh side or a light dinner.
You mostly just have to wash and chop the kale and Brussels sprouts. Whisk the dressing ingredients together and toss it into the greens.
18. Copycat Cracker Barrel Country Green Beans
I once visited Cracker Barrel with a vegetarian friend who ordered these green beans. She was surprised to find bacon in a vegetable side dish.
The waiter correctly stated that piggy makes everything better. I have made this countless times and my family eats every single bite.